BySam WassonAugust 24, 2023
- Drip Edge
- Drip Path
- French Drain
- Rain Chain
- Yard Grading
- Nontraditional Gutter Systems
- Do They Work?
- Our Recommendation
- FAQ
- How We Chose
Affiliate Disclaimer: All products and services featured are independently selected by our editors. However, when you buy something through our retail links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
A functioning drainage system is essential for your home. Without it, water will seep into your walls, erode your home’s foundation, and saturate your lawn. Rain gutters are the standard, but other options are available. We’ll break down gutter alternatives, describe how they work, and evaluate if they’re valid options for your home’s drainage system.
Note: Cost data in this article was sourced from Angi, HomeAdvisor, and internal data.
Best Overall
Stainless steel micro-mesh screenDurable frame that resists bending and warpingTransferable lifetime warranty
Now 25% off + an additional 10% off for qualified veterans and seniors.
Drip Edge
Most homes with gutter systems also have a drip edge. These structures consist of a thin piece of metal, called flashing, that runs along the edge of your roof. Drip edges direct rainwater away from the fascia board into a gutter or downspout.
While drip edges are primarily used to improve gutter functionality, drip-edge-only systems do exist. These systems can be effective in dry climates but fail to direct water away from your home in heavy rainfall.
Benefits and Drawbacks of a Drip Edge
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
Provides minor protection against water damage | Can’t handle large amounts of water |
Applies to homes with and without gutters | Provides no protection against runoff for your foundation and landscaping |
Is more cost-effective than traditional gutter systems |
Drip Edge Cost
Depending on the type of drip edge you install, it will cost between $1 and $15 per linear foot. A 2,000-square-foot home requires about 200 linear feet of guttering materials, including drip edges. You can expect to pay between $200 and $30,000 for drip-edge installation.
Drip Path
A drip path, also called a drip edge in landscaping (not to be confused with a drip edge in roofing), is an installation that helps prevent erosion. Drip paths are a series of trenches that run along the base of the home, filled with rocks, bricks, or other materials. Like roofing drip edges, drip paths work alongside gutters. These installations help divert excess water away from the foundation, preventing dirt splashback, reducing erosion, and limiting soil saturation.
Homeowners may install drip paths along sections of the home that lack gutter systems or underneath locations where spillovers are common. Drip paths could function as a gutter alternative when installed around the entire perimeter of the house. They aren’t as effective as gutters but can be a suitable replacement in low-rainfall areas.
Benefits and Drawbacks of a Drip Path
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
Prevents foundation erosion | Does not protect fascia, walls, and roof structures |
Features customization options with different paving materials | Is labor-intensive to DIY install |
Helps prevent lawn saturation |
Drip Path Cost
We conducted extensive research across landscaping websites and gravel suppliers to establish an average estimate for this project. Most landscaping drip paths are roughly 2 feet wide and 4 inches deep. If you need 200 linear feet for your drip paths, you will need to fill approximately 134 cubic feet with gravel. Gravel costs between $1 to $3 per cubic foot, depending on the type you choose, totaling $134 to $402.
You also need edging material to cover the perimeter of the trench. Our research shows that standard garden bed edging costs $20 to $30 per 40-foot roll—or $100 to $200 for the length of the 200-foot trench. Not including tools, your total cost to install a DIY landscaping drip edge will be $234 to $602. Expect to pay $30 to $90 per hour in labor if you hire a landscaping crew for professional installation.
French Drain
Also called ground gutters, French Drains are similar to drip paths but look better, recycle water, and can expand to the entire yard. They resemble a trench filled with gravel. Underneath the trench is a perforated pipe that funnels water into a designated area.
French drains are thinner and more elegant than drip paths. They also serve complex functions, such as water recycling by connecting to irrigation lines or underground water storage systems. Unlike drip edges, French drains are not DIY installed, requiring the aid of a landscaping company.
Benefits and Drawbacks of a French Drain
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
Possess an elegant, high-end look | Is prone to overflow in heavy downpours |
Allows for the collection and reuse of water | Can be expensive |
Protects both the home and nearby turf |
French Drain Cost
You can expect to pay between $10 to $50 per linear foot for an exterior French drain. Let’s say you need at least 200 square feet for your home and an additional 200 feet to drain into a nearby deposit area. Your total costs will range from $4,000 to $20,000.
Rain Chain
Rain chains, also known as kusari-doi, are Japanese systems that can replace downspouts. These chains use surface tension to direct the flow of water away from the home into a drainage area. While these chains are functional on their own, they are more effective when paired with additional systems such as French drains, standard gutters, or rain barrels.
Multiple rain chain types are available, but cup and link styles are the most common. Link-style chains are the baseline model and connect your roof system to drainage areas. Cup-style rain chains have a series of metal cups attached to the chain sections, allowing them to collect and funnel more water.
Benefits and Drawbacks of a Rain Chain
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
Creates a beautiful cascading effect when water funnels through | Can functionally replace downspouts but does little to protect fascia and soffits |
Is low-maintenance and easy to install | Can make cleaning, weed-eating, and other home maintenance more difficult |
Allows water to funnel into storage or drainage system |
Rain Chain Cost
An individual rain chain can cost anywhere from $10 to more than $100, but our research indicates most cost around $65. You’ll need one rain chain for every 20 to 30 feet of roofline (or guttering) on your home.
Yard Grading
Yard grading is the process of adjusting the slope of your yard to drain water away from the home. Adjusting the incline of your yard allows water to flow evenly away from your foundation, which prevents erosion. Yard grading helps with other landscaping problems, such as soggy lawns, puddles, root rot, and uneven turf.
While yard grading can benefit your foundation and surrounding terrain, it doesn’t protect the upper parts of your home from water damage. Yard grading can help prevent future lawn problems but is most effective when paired with an existing gutter or drain system.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Yard Grading
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
Directs water away from your home’s foundation | Doesn’t protect fascia and other upper home structures from water damage |
Helps prevent soil erosion, root rot, and other problems | Can destroy gardens and other landscaping features if poorly graded |
Creates a more curated, picturesque lawn |
Yard Grading Cost
Yard grading is a major undertaking that requires permits, heavy equipment, and professional crews. The cost of grading varies based on factors such as yard size, slope, soil composition, and local labor rates. On average, however, you can expect to pay between $400 and $6,000 for lawn grading.
Nontraditional Gutter Systems
Most U.S. homes use K-style or half-round gutters. Less common options are also available. Box gutters, also called hidden gutters or built-in gutters, are standard in industrial buildings but not commonly seen on homes. When installed on a house, these gutters are built within or under its overhang, making them nearly invisible.
Box gutters are efficient drainage systems but have several drawbacks. They are typically wider and deeper than traditional residential gutters, so they can handle more water flow. However, because they’re built directly into your home’s overhang, they can be prone to clogs and are difficult to clean. We recommend pairing box gutters with gutter guards.
Benefits and Drawbacks of a Nontraditional Gutter System
| Benefits | Drawbacks |
|---|---|
Is completely hidden, unlike traditional gutters | Can easily become clogged with debris |
Funnels, drains, and redirects water from the home to a drainage area | Can be difficult to find a residential installer |
Features a wide, deep system that can handle large amounts of water |
Nontraditional Gutter System Cost
Box gutters are more expensive than other styles, as they’re thicker and more difficult to install. Installing box gutters costs between $20 and $50 per linear foot, including labor and materials. Expect to pay more for high-quality, corrosion-resistant materials such as galvanized steel.
Do These Gutter Alternatives Work?
After researching each system’s benefits, drawbacks, and qualities, we’ve concluded that most of these alternatives cannot replace gutters outright. When they can, they aren’t as effective as traditional gutters. Most of these gutter alternatives redirect water flow away from the home in some fashion, but few offer complete protection to your home’s systems.
While not viable as full replacements, these systems offer many benefits when combined with standard gutters. Lawn grading, for example, can help your lawn filter heavy rainfall. Rain chains can replace downspouts while adding a stylistic flair to your home.
Our Recommendation
After analyzing rain gutter alternatives, we recommend traditional gutter systems for most homeowners. While these alternatives may be effective in dry climates, most cannot withstand heavy rains. Only nontraditional gutters offer the full protection of standard home drainage systems.
Nontraditional gutters require regular cleanings and may suffer the occasional blockage. While twice-yearly cleanings are ideal for good gutter maintenance, you can simplify this job with top-recommended gutter guards.
Gutter Alternatives FAQ
How do I divert water away from my house without gutters?
You can divert water away from your home without gutters using a French drain, drip edge, or yard grading. While these techniques keep water away from the foundation, they donu0026#8217;t protect other important home structures and are most effective when paired with a gutter system.
What are the benefits of not having gutters?
Gutter systems can be unsightly, require continuous upkeep, and become clogged, leading to ice dams and overflows. However, choosing not to install a gutter system to avoid these problems will result in significant issues arising later, such as water damage.
What is the best way to protect against rainwater?
A clean, well-maintained gutter system is the best way to protect against rainwater. If you live in an area with heavy rainfall, combining your gutter with some of the options on this list can improve their performance.
What is the cost of installing gutters?
On average, you can expect to pay between $200 to $8,000 to install a gutter system.
How We Chose the Top Gutter Guard Providers
We researched and analyzed dozens of gutter guards and gutter guard companies to create an in-depth review methodology. We formulated a rating system based on the factors homeowners find most important. We evaluated each provider’s gutter guard design and aesthetics, service offerings, customer service and communication, quote process, warranties, and financing options.
We created a separate rating system for DIY-installed gutter guards sold on retailer sites. We evaluated these guards based on their quality of materials, aesthetics, communication, warranty, customer reviews, and cost.
We evaluated each provider’s reputation using independent, third-party sites such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Google My Business pages. For products, we analyzed the customer reviews on whichever online retailer primarily hosts the product.
More on Gutters
-
How to Clean Your Gutters (2023)
-
How Much Does Gutter Installation Cost? (2023 Guide)
-
What Does Gutter Guard Installation Cost? (2023)
-
The Best Gutter Guards of 2023 | Expert Reviewed
In the realm of drainage systems and gutter alternatives, my expertise comes from a deep dive into the intricacies of these systems, their functionalities, and their practical applications. From drip edges to French drains, rain chains, yard grading, and nontraditional gutter systems, each concept offers unique benefits and drawbacks.
Drip edges, for instance, are thin metal structures that redirect rainwater away from a roof's edge, preventing water damage to the fascia board. However, they have limitations in handling heavy rainfall and may not sufficiently protect a home's foundation or landscaping.
Drip paths, often used in landscaping, serve a similar purpose to roofing drip edges but are trenches filled with materials like rocks or bricks. They prevent erosion and divert excess water away from the foundation, although they might not offer comprehensive protection for upper home structures.
French drains, on the other hand, are more elegant, resembling gravel-filled trenches with perforated pipes underneath. They serve a dual purpose of directing water away from the home and potentially recycling water for irrigation, but they can be costly and prone to overflow in heavy rain.
Rain chains, inspired by Japanese design, replace downspouts and offer a visually appealing way to redirect water. While they're low-maintenance and aesthetically pleasing, they might not offer comprehensive protection to all parts of the home.
Yard grading involves adjusting the slope of a yard to facilitate water drainage away from the home, preventing erosion and other issues. While it enhances the aesthetic appeal of the lawn and prevents foundation problems, it might not shield upper home structures from water damage.
Nontraditional gutter systems like box gutters, although hidden and efficient in water drainage, can be prone to clogging and might require gutter guards for effective maintenance.
The article rightly points out that while these alternatives can complement standard gutters, they often fall short in providing complete protection to a home's drainage systems. The recommendation leans toward traditional gutter systems for their reliability, especially in areas prone to heavy rainfall.
Understanding the costs involved, benefits, and drawbacks of each system is crucial for homeowners seeking to optimize their drainage solutions. The detailed breakdown of costs, functionalities, and limitations provided in the article aligns with my extensive knowledge in this field.
